Kalvin Phillips’ fall from grace at Manchester City compared to Dele Alli as ex-star critiques Guardiola’s influence

Kalvin Phillips, signed by Manchester City for £42 million in 2022 after a successful stint at Leeds, has struggled to make an impact, with only 31 appearances for the club.

Kalvin Phillips Compared To Dele Alli
Francois Nel/Getty Images and George Wood/Getty Images

After an impressive spell at Leeds, Phillips was acquired by Manchester City for £42 million ($52m) in the summer of 2022. However, his career has stagnated since then, with only 31 appearances across all competitions for the Premier League champions. Phillips was loaned to West Ham for the second half of the 2023-24 season but faced heavy criticism for his performances in East London as well.

The 28-year-old’s struggles have drawn comparisons to Dele Alli, once regarded as one of England’s brightest midfield talents during his time at Tottenham. Alli’s career also declined, leading to his sidelining for the entire last season at Everton due to injury.

Ex-Liverpool and Aston Villa player Dean Saunders highlighted the similarities when discussing Phillips’ difficulties under Pep Guardiola on talkSPORT. Saunders remarked, “We’ve seen it happen to Dele Alli. Dele Alli became disillusioned and suddenly, what’s happened to him? I remember Dele Alli bursting into the box past Harry Kane, making goals. With Kalvin Phillips, he used to intercept, keep it simple, pass to others who could advance play. Now, he’s lost all his belief and confidence. When your confidence goes, if I went eight games without scoring, I couldn’t even control the ball. Everything becomes an effort, and you start thinking you’re a bad player. That’s what’s happened to him.”

Phillips is not expected to find much success at City this season, as the English champions are likely to transfer him during the current window. Aston Villa has been linked with a move for the 28-year-old in recent weeks.

Kalvin Phillips

Kalvin Phillips

Defender, Midfielder

EnglandEngland

Age: 29

179 cm

72 kg

Season 2024
Played 3 0 Missed
Minutes 180 60.0 Avg
Goals 0 0.0 Avg
Assist 0 0.0 Avg
Attempt 0 0.0 Avg
Passes 53 17.730.0% AvgSucc
Yellow 0 0.0 Avg
Red 0 0.0 Avg

Manchester City performance and stats

Manchester City

Manager: Josep Guardiola
Top 3 Scorers
Last season

Dele Alli

Bamidele Alli

Forwarder, Midfielder

EnglandEngland

Age: 28

188 cm

76 kg

Everton performance and stats

Everton

Manager: Sean Dyche
Top 3 Scorers
This season